|
|
| About site: Transportation and Logistics/Rail/Training and Safety - How the FRA is Regulating Passenger Rail Out of Existence |
Return to Business
|
| About site: http://www.ebbc.org/rail/fra.html |
Title: Transportation and Logistics/Rail/Training and Safety - How the FRA is Regulating Passenger Rail Out of Existence Site critical of Federal Railway Administration crash requirements for passenger rail.
|
|
|
|
|
National_Transportation_Safety_Board_-_Railroads Links to publications, board minutes and reports of railroad accident investigations. [more]
| Peter_J__Rose Specializing in Fire, Safety & Security Training for Industry and Industrial and Shortline Railways. Manual Track Inspection to FRA and TC (RAC) Standards. [more]
| Railway_Safety_and_Standards_Board A not-for-profit company operating as a centre of excellence for all matters relating to railway safety. [more]
| Railway_Signalling_Design_Training_for_the_UK UK signalling design courses and other related services for the UK rail industry. [more]
| Signal_Training_Solutions Offering apprentice programs or individual courses on specific signal equipment. Includes overview of services, class schedule and news. [more]
| Signet_Solutions An engineer led rail training and consultancy company with international experience, based in Derby UK. [more]
|
|
| Alexa statistic for http://www.ebbc.org/rail/fra.html |
|
| Related sites for http://www.ebbc.org/rail/fra.html |
| S&T_Training_Ltd UK based provider of rail training and track safety courses. | | Track_Access_Solutions_Ltd_ UK based provider of driver route learning software, route maps, and computer based training packages for the rail industry. | | UK_Health_and_Safety_Executive_-_Rail_Safety Information on rail health and safety issues. | | The_Yellow_Book_-_Engineering_Safety_Management A handbook, published by Railtrack on behalf of the UK rail industry, designed to help people involved in changes to the railway contribute to improved safety. | | Creative_Freelancers Directory of, and jobs for freelance writers, designers, web design and developers, illustrators, photographers, creatives of all types. | | Creative_Moonlighter Matches potential employers with moonlighting freelancers for web design, copywriting, advertising, graphic design, and writing projects. | | Freelance_Writers UK marketplace for freelance writers and project providers. | | FreelanceDirect_Net Small listing of freelancers seeking clients and clients seeking freelancers. | | Freelance-Exchange Provider of graphic designers and illustrators for contract or temporary hire. | | FreelanceJobSearch_com Database of freelancers looking for work, and employers' job postings for freelance gigs. | | Freelance-Proofreaders UK marketplace for project providers and freelance proofreaders, copy editors, and document producers. | | New_Media_Freelancers_-_UK A contact database for freelancers and contractors working in the UK New Media industry. | | Portfolios_com Searchable directory of creative professionals. Includes portfolios and detailed work profiles of: Photographers, Illustrators, Graphic Designers, Industrial Designers, Animators, Interactive Designe | | Qfolio Online portfolio building and hosting for creative professionals in the visual arts and design trades. | | Stridepool_com Online diary service and searchable directory of creative UK freelancers. | | TheAntsNest_com A network of creative South Africans from every creative design, advertising or marketing category servicing clients worldwide. | | Xchangeteam Matches UK business needs with freelance consultants' skills, principally in the areas of marketing and advertising. | | Gavin_Mckinney Bahamas based underwater production specialists offering underwater camera work, shark staging, stunt and marine coordination. Credits include five James Bond movies. | | Helifilms_Ltd Specializes in making films from air-borne or moving vehicles. The site also contains a library of purchaseable film clips and a themed entertainment industry directory. | | Meringue_Productions Provides multimedia and interactive programs for children and for in-flight entertainment. | | Care_Logistics_(Pvt)_Ltd Colombo, Sri Lanka based company also offering consolidation and transhipment. | | Crown_Air_&_Sea_(Taiwan)_Ltd_ Air freight, ocean freight, and international logistic service based in Taiwan and Hong Kong. | | G2K_Forwarding_Services,__Pte__Ltd Based in Singapore, with office in Malaysia (Kuala Lumpur). Offering ocean, air freight forwarding, storage, local distribution and customs clearance services. | | Trans_Asia_C__S__Co__Ltd Provides freight forwarding, aircraft chartering, customs, and warehousing services, serving many southeast Asian countries. | | Trico_Navigation_(Pvt)_Ltd Company based in Sri Lanka and offering services in national, regional and international logistics. Containerized, conventional and project cargo. | | World_Gate_Express_Lines Offices in Singapore and throughout India. Specialist in air and ocean shipping between India, Singapore and major world ports. | | All_China_Sources_Online An utmost innovative, creative, and comprehensive B2B portal site with full directory database of China manufactures, suppliers, exporters. | | Hong_Kong_Optical_Manufacturers_Directory Profiles over 70 Hong Kong optical, glasses, frame, and eyewear manufacturers that export. Listings include address, phone, fax, email, contact name, products, distribution, and investment company. | | Korean_Marketplace Search Korean manufacturers by keyword or product category (HS number), and access web sites, or request information. The site claims a database 10,000 companies and 50,000 products, and provides indu | | Trade_India Database of Indian exporters and importers. | | All_Taiwan_Products_Online Directory of Sourcing Taiwan & China products and suppliers, manufacturers, exporters for volume buyers. (May 18, 2001) | | AIM_-_Hotel_Management_Academy School in France offering a hotel management degree and certification programs in French and English. The study programs are licensed in the United States by American Hotel and Lodging Association. | | Birmingham_College_of_Food_Tourism_and_Creative_Studies A United Kingdom institution for vocational and higher education programs in the fields of hospitality, tourism and leisure management. | | Blue_Mountains_Hotel_School Undergraduate and postgraduate level courses in hospitality and tourism management combining practical and theoretical training. Accredited in Australia. | | California_Culinary_Academy Offers a restaurant management degree program and a hospitality degree program for people wanting to start their career in hospitality; based in San Francisco. | | Canadian_Tourism_College Travel, and tourism oriented training programs offered on line and on site in British Columbia, Canada. | | Conrad_N__Hilton_College_of_Hotel_and_Restaurant_Management Courses at graduate and under graduate levels for the hospitality sector, on campus as well as on line. | | Culinary_Arts_Schools Profiles culinary arts schools in the U.S. and Canada offering Le Cordon Bleu certificate and degree programs for aspiring chefs. | | Food_Hygiene_Training Online traing for the RIPH Foundation Certificate in Food Hygiene | | Glion_Hotel_School Hotel and tourism school in Switzerland. History of the school, campus locations at Glion and Bulle, course details and accreditation. |
|
This is businessgiftdepot.com cache of m/ as retrieved on 2009.01.07 businessgiftdepot.com's cache is the snapshot that we took of the page as we crawled the web. The page may have changed since that time.
|
How the FRA is Regulating Passenger Rail Out of Existence | East Bay Bicycle Coalition @import url(http://www.ebbc.org/sites/all/modules/civicrm/css/civicrm.css); @import "/modules/aggregator/aggregator.css";@import "/modules/book/book.css";@import "/modules/node/node.css";@import "/modules/poll/poll.css";@import "/modules/system/defaults.css";@import "/modules/system/system.css";@import "/modules/user/user.css";@import "/sites/all/modules/cck/content.css";@import "/sites/all/modules/event/event.css";@import "/sites/all/modules/gallery/gallery.css";@import "/sites/all/modules/gallery/gallery_filter.css";@import "/sites/all/modules/mailhandler/mailhandler.css";@import "/sites/all/modules/quiz/quiz.css";@import "/sites/all/modules/quote/quote.css";@import "/sites/all/modules/cck/fieldgroup.css";@import "/modules/comment/comment.css";@import "/themes/zen/zen_classic/style.css";@import "/themes/zen/tabs.css";@import "/themes/zen/zen_classic/html-elements.css";@import "/themes/zen/zen_classic/layout-garland.css";@import "/themes/zen/zen_classic/icons.css";@import "/themes/zen/zen_classic/zen-classic.css";  East Bay Bicycle Coalition Promoting bicycling as an everyday means of transportation and recreation since 1972 AboutContactJoin HomeCampaignsHazardsMapsNewsletterSafetyShopsTheft Eric McCaughrin's Blog Pages FilmHall of ShamePassenger Rail IssuesBART-San Jose ExtensionBikes and trainsHigh speed rail projects from around the worldHow the FRA is Regulating Passenger Rail Out of ExistenceMTC Releases Draft Regional Rail Plan Navigation blogscontentforumsGalleryRecent postssite map User login Username: * Password: * Create new accountRequest new password Transit newswire 50% more Muni fare evaders caught after inspectors increasedBART may reduce evening and Sunday service to cut costs6-year-old tries driving family car to school after missing busIn Palo Alto, bicycle sales cruising despite recessionBay Area road pavement averages 'fair' rating in MTC reportmore Home :: Eric McCaughrin's Blog Pages :: Passenger Rail Issues :: How the FRA is Regulating Passenger Rail Out of Existence Submitted by Eric McCaughrin on March 5, 2007 - 1:23pm. in Amtrak/ACELegislation What if the FAA required that jet aircraft be able to survive crashes into the ground? Or if the FHA said automobiles had to survive any head-on crash at 60 mph into a tractor trailer without deformation? Even if such vehicles could be engineered, they would be far too costly to operate. But for passenger trains, that is precisely what the FRA has been doing.It is an arcane government agency few ever heard of. The Federal Railroad Administration was created in 1966 to set and enforce railway safety standards. And certainly in terms of safety, the FRA has been wildly successful passenger rail is perhaps the safest mode of transport in the US. But many rail advocates argue that the FRA regulations have not only come at too high a price (by making rail prohibitively expensive) but in many cases are completely nonsensical.The Acela FiascoAmtrak's botched attempt at a high-speed train is a good case study in the problems caused by the FRA. As originally designed, the Acela was supposed to provide high-speed rail service on the Northeast Corridor (NEC) between Boston, New York, and Washington DC with speeds as high as 150 mph. In order to procure the world's best off-the-shelf train for the least amount of money, Amtrak decided to buy an existing design from a European or Japanese manufacturer, who have decades of experience building and operating high-speed trains. The winner of this competition was a consortium of Bombadier and Alstom (the French TGV builder).Then, in 1999 with Acela planning fully underway,the FRA pulled the rug out by issuing regulations for high-speed rail service requiring trains to withstand 800,000 pounds force without deformation. The 800,000 figure is an arbitrary number dating back to the 1920s; this mandate has since been increased to 1 million pounds.The buffering requirement confounded Bombadier. Train weight is of crucial importance as it affects the amount of track wear, noise, and energy costs. To meet the buffering regulation, the train would have to be significantly bulked-up. The result was a highspeed train nearly twice as heavy as its European counterparts. As such, the Acela has been described variously as a tank-on-wheels and a bank-vault-on-wheels. Indeed, an overweight train like Acela would be banned from the European high speed rail network.Because the extra weight put so much strain on the train body (which was never designed to handle suchloads) trainsets suffered excessive wheel wear, cracks in the yaw damper and brake rotors, and other problems which can probably never be completely fixed. Whereas the original contract called for trains to run 400,000 miles between equipment failures, the Acela can barely manage 20,000 miles.Buffering StandardsFRA staffers point out that it is unfair to compare US buffering standards with those in Europe because passenger rail in the US has to contend with more (and heavier) freight traffic. Like the soccer-Mom who thinks an SUV provides greater safety, the FRA figures collisions are inevitable and heavier is better. And just as an SUV is a hazard to other road users, the same is true with the Acela. Amtrak bitterly complained that the heavier Acela trains would be potentially lethal against lighter commuter trains on the NEC in the event of a collision.And heaver trains are a lot more expensive to operate, which means higher fares and fewer trains running to fewer places. This in turn means travelers often resort to driving cars, which is 10-100 times more dangerous than rail travel. In other words, even if one accepts the premise that the excessive US buffering standards make train travel safer, they may in fact be counterproductive by diverting potential train riders to automobiles, causing many times more highway fatalities. The TGV builders are famous for the efforts that have gone into weight reduction, such as this prototype honeycomb graphite composite carbody (photo: TGVweb).Commuter Rail Even when there is zero possibility of a passenger train colliding with a freight train, FRA buffering regulations still apply. These days, there are virtually no freight trains running on the Caltrain line, but Caltrain must still run its overweight, polluting, fuel gulping dinosaurs because the line connects to the national rail network.The situation is particularly absurd when one looks at the Long Island Commuter Railroad (LIRR) in New York City, which has no freight traffic and a modern, automatic train control system to prevent collisions. Technically, it is still a freight railroad subject to FRA rules. Thus, the new M-7 railcars purchased by the New York MTA weigh an astonishing 125,000 lbs -- twice the weight of a non-FRA compliant BART car on the off-chance an LIRR might collide with a 100-ton coal train in Manhattan.Train Safety in the Rest of the WorldEuropean and Japanese rail operators believe the best way to survive a train accident is to simply not have one in the first place. Their design philosophy is to rely on modern signaling and proper maintenance to prevent collisions and derailments.There are also smarter, better ways to improve accident survivability than just running heavier trains. One ingenious solution is the articulated cars used by the French TGV and Spanish Talgo. Whereas traditional railcars are joined by a simple coupler, an articulated train (as shown in the diagram) physically connects two railcars to the same truck so that they function as a single unit. This not only saves weight (by eliminating one truck per car) but increases the stability of the trainset. Also, it significantly reduces the chances of the train jack-knifing which has been credited with saving lives on a number of occasions (see TGV accidents). An articulated train (see TGVweb).Implications for the Bay AreaAssuming California's budget mess can be fixed, the California High Speed Rail Commission (CAHSR) will build a 224 mph Los Angeles-San Francisco rail service. Because it may run on conventional tracks in urban areas, the trains might have to satisfy FRA Tier II rules. Officially, the CAHSR has no problem with the rules, but many question how the system could achieve operational self-sufficiency. An Acela-type train would incur prohibitively high track maintenance and electricity costs.As well, the FRA rules could make it more expensive to implement the "eBART" type DMU extensions currently being studied by BART. A DMU is basically a bus on steel wheels. In Europe there are thousands of low-cost DMUs providing rail service to remote towns and villages, with populations as small as 4000 persons. It would be hard to provide a similar type of service in the US as long as the FRA requires DMUs to lug around tons of deadweight. In both Europe and Japan, a competitive business exists in the DMU marketplace. But that market is off limits to US transit agencies because the FRA has effectively created a trade embargo. A company like Siemens would incur prohibitively high retooling costs in order to redesign its products for a niche market. With no manufacturers available, transit agencies wanting to use DMU equipment in the US have had to take extraordinary measures. Sonoma-Marin rail planners, for example, at one point seriously studied the use of refurbished Budd RDC cars -- which were manufactured some 50 years ago! In effect, a rolling museum on rails. eBART Artist Rendition 13 Budd RDC cars were refurbished for use on the "Trinity Rail Express" in Dallas. With modern European and Japanese equipment off-limits, this antiquated 1950's design is one of the few vehicles available to transit agencies running under FRA rules.Hills and CurvesIn the mountainous West, the FRA mandates make it impossible to run competitive rail service in hilly terrain. The deadweight necessitates low speed and/or excessive fuel consumption when climbing hills. On heavily-used passenger lines, greater weight reduces the amount of safe unbalanced superelevation i.e. how fast a train can go around curves. Because of the Acela's inability to navigate curves on the New Haven line, a trip on the Acela Express from New York to Boston loses 30 minutes compared to best practice in tilt train usage and eliminating that 30 minutes by straightening curves would cost on the order of $1 billion. The JR Hokkaido series 281 represents industry best practice in tilt DMU. The 3 hours it takes to travel the 200 mile Sapporo-Hakodate route on a line that is one-third curved is a very respectable result. The new 281 reduced journey time by 47 minutes and killed off air service between the two cities (see JR Hokkaido Keeps Ice and Snow at Bay and Railway Operators in Japan). Japan operates the world's lightest and safest trains, but according to the FRA the 281 is unsafe.Horn BlowingImagine you are at a railroad crossing. The gates are down, lights are flashing, bells ringing, a big giant locomotive with flashing lights can be seen speeding down the track. Heading out across the tracks would be crazy, but nonetheless 600 Darwin Award candidates get killed each year -- usually by driving around the gates because they are too impatient to wait 30 seconds for the train to pass.Would it make any difference to these drivers if the locomotive were also blasting a 100 decibel horn? The FRA seemed to think so. Traditionally, horn blasting regulations were determined locally, but in 1995 the FRA began a rulemaking process to Federalize regulations and in the process dramatically increase horn blasting by going after so-called "Quiet Zones" -- i.e. places where whistle blowing was prohibited. Armed with a study that showed as many as 3(!) fatalities a year could be prevented, the FRA proposed rule would only allow Quiet Zones exemptions at crossings that had been improved with "four-quadrant" gates and curb medians. In Illinois, which has 900 of the nearly 2000 whistle bans nationwide, cash-strapped local government would have to spend $116-234 million to meet the Federal mandate. Ironically, the FRA's own numbers show that in Illinois, collisions at crossing with hornblowing bans were actually 4.5% less frequent than at crossings where horns were sounded.Many communities throughout the US sprung up along rail lines. In the greater Chicago area (a major rail hub) some 1.2 million residents live within one quarter mile of a grade crossing. In Beverly, MA (a suburb of Boston) the lifting of the horn ban on the city's 17 crossings would result in an average of two horns blowing every minute of every day. Unlike other light rail systems in the nation, the NJT "River Line" is subject to FRA rules because it was built along an old freight spur. Thus, trains (which run every 15 minutes) have to blast their horn at each intersection, aggravating nearby residents (photo: NYC Subway).Legitimate homeowner complaints over horn blasting makes it difficult to build political support for increased rail service. In her testimony before Congress, Rita Mullins, Mayor of Palatine, Illinois, notes the conflicting policies between Federal agencies: "In order to clean our air, reduce auto congestion, and improve quality of life, several federal agencies including the EPA, HUD and the Federal Transit Administration are encouraging Transit Oriented Development. The idea behind this type of development is to bring residents closer to train stations, so that they can use mass transportation, and so that downtown revitalization can occur. At the same time, the proposed train horn rule in effect is discouraging the development community and our residents from locating around transit."A great example of how this inconsistency in policy plays out is in the Village of Arlington Heights, Illinois. In the last several years, this village directly to the east of my community has invested over $30 million of its own money to spur transit-oriented development in its downtown. 330 higher density residential units are currently under construction, and an additional 300 are planned. 45 new businesses have moved into the downtown development to support the new residential community."Arlington Heights Mayor Arlene Mulder tells me she has spoken to residents who have purchased condominiums next to the train station who tell her they do not want to stay if faced with train horns around the clock. And they will hear them around the clock. Both freight and commuter trains run through her village and mine an average of seventy times daily. Developments such as this should be encouraged, not squelched by conflicting federal policies."LinksUS DOT Secretary Rodney Slater praises new Tier II crash standardsGAO Report on Acela ProblemsThe Shasta Route - Explanation of curve speeds in this interesting web page on a proposed Sacramento-Portland passenger rail service.‹ High speed rail projects from around the worldupMTC Releases Draft Regional Rail Plan › Printer-friendly versionLogin or register to post comments  Upcoming events Regular meeting of the Albany Strollers and Rollers(3 days)Free Hands-on Bicycle Classes at REI Berkeley(4 days)Emeryville Bicycle Pedestrian Advisory Committee(5 days)Alameda County Active Transportation Forum(8 days)What about bicycle access and safety? Oakland Oak to Ninth Public Hearing (13 days)TransForm Regional Meeting - Safe Streets for All (14 days)Add event more Events « January 2009 » SunMonTueWedThuFriSat 123 45678910 11121314151617 18192021222324 25262728293031 Active forum topics Critical Mass?Caldecott Decision expected soonHit & Run horror in Richmond kills bicyclistBerkeley PD blame the vicitm?New bike parking device from Japan.more Recent blog posts Memorial Ride Editorial of The Argus, December 12, 2008New Year Celebration on Mt DiabloAmazing Transformation of New York City StreetsBest Alternative Transport Movie Chases"The Joys of Life on Two Wheels"Invitation for Bus Shelter Art Emeryville Bike PatrolJanuary meeting dateIn-depth precinct analysis of anti-BRT measure KK resultsThey Don't Teach This in Bicycle Classesmore Promoting bicycling as an everyday means of transportation and recreation since 1972 |
|
| |
Site | critical | of | Federal | Railway | Administration | crash | requirements | for | passenger | rail. |
|
http://www.ebbc.org/rail/fra.html
How the FRA is Regulating Passenger Rail Out of Existence 2009 January
dvd rental
dvd
Site critical of Federal Railway Administration crash requirements for passenger rail.
Rules
|
© 2005 Internet Explorer 5+ or Netscape 6+
|
|
Recommended Sites: 1.
Arts -
Business -
Computers -
Games -
Health -
Home -
Kids and Teens -
News -
Recreation -
Reference -
Regional -
Science -
Shopping -
Society -
Sports -
World
Miss Gallery
- Top Anime Hentai
- DVD rental by mail
- MPAA - Internet Advertising - McDonalds - Bankruptcy - Bollywood Wallpapers
|
